HB 111 and the Jewish Community: Facts Over Campaign Narratives

A recent op-ed attacking my record on antisemitism was far from a neutral analysis. In fact, it was a campaign attack written by a declared candidate for this office, presented as concern for the Jewish community. Voters should understand that what was framed as advocacy is, in reality, a political narrative built on misrepresentation.

Let’s begin with what should not be in dispute. Combating antisemitism is a priority for me, both personally and as a legislator representing a district with a large and vibrant Jewish community. Florida is widely recognized as a national leader in addressing antisemitism through strong, proactive legislative action, and my record reflects that commitment.

The claim that I “failed” my Jewish constituents by opposing HB 111 is simply false.

I advanced HB 111 through committee in good faith to allow for debate, stakeholder engagement and improvement. That is how the legislative process works. Moving a bill forward does not signal unconditional support, it ensures the opportunity to get the policy correct. Suggesting otherwise is either a misunderstanding of the process or a deliberate attempt to mislead readers.

My concerns with HB 111 were substantive and consistent. At the core is a simple question: should Florida continue leading through accountable legislative action, or shift responsibility into a new bureaucratic structure influenced by outside organizations?

Florida became a national leader through decisive legislative action, not by outsourcing policy. That leadership was built even when outside organizations disagreed with key measures, including our anti BDS law and the codification of a uniform definition of antisemitism. Ignoring that history while portraying any organization as beyond scrutiny is not a serious analysis.

Transparency was also a central issue. HB 111 relied heavily on advocacy and data from the Anti Defamation League. When policy is built on outside data, full disclosure is not optional. I made a straightforward request that the underlying data be shared, including data that has not been publicly disclosed regarding patterns and sources of antisemitism. That is a basic standard of accountability, not a controversial position.

These concerns are not theoretical. The FBI recently ended its formal relationship with the ADL, reinforcing the need for policymakers to independently evaluate the credibility and completeness of the information used to guide public policy. That reality was entirely omitted from the op-ed.

Recent high profile antisemitic incidents further underscore why complete and honest data matters. Effective policy depends on confronting reality, not filtering it. Legislators cannot responsibly craft solutions if relevant information is withheld or selectively presented.

Instead of engaging with these facts, the op-ed reduces a serious policy discussion to a false choice: support this bill or be accused of failing the Jewish community. That is not only inaccurate, it is irresponsible.

Turning antisemitism into a political talking point is not leadership. It weakens the credibility of efforts to confront it.

Throughout this process, I acted in good faith. I advanced the bill, raised legitimate questions, sought transparency, proposed improvements and worked toward stronger, more accountable policy. That is what responsible lawmaking requires.

What the op-ed ultimately demonstrates is not insight into the legislative process, but a willingness to distort it for political gain. The Jewish community deserves better than to have its very real concerns used as a backdrop for campaign messaging.

Antisemitism is real, and it demands serious, effective action. That requires policymaking grounded in transparency, accountability and evidence, not bureaucracy or political spin.

I will continue to stand on my record and remain committed to advancing policies that are effective, responsible and rooted in fact. Voters deserve honesty, not narratives designed for an election cycle.

Fabián Basabe
#fabianforflorida
fabianbasabe.com

---

Connect To Your Customers & Grow Your Business

Click Here

---